In case you're wondering where the Newbery winners starred review post went... Well, evidently I made several mistakes in my calculations. I'm going back over my research and retabulating, and I'll put the post back up if/when I'm 100% sure I have it right.
(Head to desk, face to palm, and various other expressions of personal chagrin.)
Sorry about that! Yet another reason to be grateful for Elizabeth Bluemle and her list.
ETA: I think I'm going to turn this into a larger project. It's more challenging than I anticipated.